mudcat.org: Dylan's use of Trad music?
Lyrics & Knowledge Personal Pages Record Shop Auction Links Radio & Media Kids Membership Help
The Mudcat Cafeawe

Post to this Thread - Printer Friendly - Home
Page: [1] [2] [3]


Dylan's use of Trad music?

Related threads:
Dylan's œuvre sold (25)
Bob Dylan: Nobel laureate (412)
Review: Bob Dylan: 2017 Thoughts (2)
Why didn't MacColl like Dylan? (517)
Review: New Dylan Album-Shadows in the Night (45)
Stolen melodies/Bob Dylan (113)
Bob Dylan 50yr. hoax (44)
The Man Who Yelled 'Judas!' to Bob Dylan (32)
Dylan to be awarded Medal of Freedom (46)
Dylan Talking Nonsense ? (48)
Bob Dylan 70yrs on 24th May..... (22)
Dylan Plays Vietnam (12)
Bob Dylan: Happy 69th birthday (15)
Joni Mitchell -Dylan is 'a plagiarist' (108)
Dylan Christmas CD !!!!! (75)
He's 68 (but he says he's 54) (7)
Happy Birthday Bob Dylan (35)
A new career for Bob [Dylan]? (3)
DylanOnTube-PBS/ScorseseDocumentary (164)
Sale: Robert Zimmerman Notes (12)
Joan Baez- uncensored Dylan Movie (94)
Dylan Profiled on 12-5-04 - CBS's 60 Minutes (8)
Dylan: Rock Legend, Maybe Folk Legend? (81)
Dylan Watch: Events Coming for 60 (24)
Happy Birthday Bobby Zimmerman (May 2000) (21)


Snuffy 10 Nov 05 - 08:34 AM
Paco Rabanne 10 Nov 05 - 03:33 AM
sharyn 09 Nov 05 - 11:55 PM
gloopy 16 Mar 02 - 08:33 AM
Little Hawk 14 Mar 02 - 06:08 PM
GUEST,Jack of Hearts 14 Mar 02 - 04:17 PM
dick greenhaus 13 Mar 02 - 11:35 PM
kytrad (Jean Ritchie) 13 Mar 02 - 06:58 PM
Little Hawk 13 Mar 02 - 03:57 PM
gloopy 13 Mar 02 - 05:53 AM
Little Hawk 12 Mar 02 - 03:45 PM
gloopy 12 Mar 02 - 06:26 AM
Little Hawk 10 Mar 02 - 08:40 PM
Noreen 10 Mar 02 - 08:02 PM
JudyR 10 Mar 02 - 07:41 PM
Noreen 10 Mar 02 - 07:18 PM
JudyR 10 Mar 02 - 06:56 PM
Little Hawk 10 Mar 02 - 12:46 PM
GUEST,Pixie 10 Mar 02 - 09:40 AM
Mr Red 10 Mar 02 - 09:31 AM
Little Hawk 10 Mar 02 - 12:48 AM
dick greenhaus 09 Mar 02 - 09:57 PM
Little Hawk 09 Mar 02 - 08:20 PM
GUEST 09 Mar 02 - 06:29 PM
bbelle 21 May 00 - 11:43 AM
Terry K 21 May 00 - 07:04 AM
catspaw49 21 May 00 - 01:40 AM
GUEST,RJE 21 May 00 - 01:22 AM
Rick Fielding 21 May 00 - 12:39 AM
GUEST,BluTrane 21 May 00 - 12:38 AM
TheOldMole 21 May 00 - 12:23 AM
GUEST,John Twomey 21 May 00 - 12:02 AM
GUEST,Okiemockbird 20 May 00 - 12:53 PM
GUEST,Mrbisok@aol 20 May 00 - 06:46 AM
GUEST,Okiemockbird 19 May 00 - 10:33 AM
GUEST,Syd, Ottawa 19 May 00 - 12:45 AM
Sandy Paton 18 May 00 - 10:14 PM
GUEST,James 18 May 00 - 11:38 AM
Whistle Stop 18 May 00 - 11:29 AM
GUEST,Okiemockbird 18 May 00 - 10:59 AM
zander (inactive) 18 May 00 - 10:23 AM
Terry K 18 May 00 - 12:22 AM
Mike Regenstreif 17 May 00 - 05:22 PM
Jim the Bart 17 May 00 - 11:59 AM
GUEST,Okiemockbird 17 May 00 - 09:36 AM
Whistle Stop 17 May 00 - 08:46 AM
Sandy Paton 17 May 00 - 12:46 AM
Sandy Paton 17 May 00 - 12:28 AM
paddyc 16 May 00 - 10:49 PM
Margaret V 16 May 00 - 10:03 PM
Share Thread
more
Lyrics & Knowledge Search [Advanced]
DT  Forum
Sort (Forum) by:relevance date
DT Lyrics:








Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Snuffy
Date: 10 Nov 05 - 08:34 AM

Sharyna, Sharyna, gal where you bin so long?


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Paco Rabanne
Date: 10 Nov 05 - 03:33 AM

100, On a Dylan thread, what joy!!


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: sharyn
Date: 09 Nov 05 - 11:55 PM

I opened up this old thread (can of worms?) when searching for commentaries on "World Gone Wrong," which I've just fallen in love with -- the song and the CD.

A comment for Dick G.: it had never occurred to me that "Farewell Angelina" was a version of "Farewell to Tarwathie," melodically. In this case, I have to say, in my opinion, "Farewell Angelina" is far more interesting, lyrically and melodically. And I am a dyed-in-the-wool ballad singer as well as a songwriter (saying so might prevent a few of you from jumping down my throat. Then again, it may not. So be it).


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: gloopy
Date: 16 Mar 02 - 08:33 AM

Dylan's latest, Love and Theft is brimming over with lyrical and musical "appropraitions" Apart from the inclusion of the words 'for Charley Paton' in the title of High Water there is no reference to any of this. I guess when you've been subject to the amount of adulation and ridicule (Justified and unjustified)you become disassociated to criticism, at least on topics like this. He'aint changin' his theivin'ways fo'no man gotta problem, take it to the boss


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Little Hawk
Date: 14 Mar 02 - 06:08 PM

Dick - Thanks, as always for the chuckle! You are such a droll fellow. In my opinion Bob's rewrites of trad songs are, with virtually no exceptions, markedly superior to the originals...but it's a matter of individual taste, isn't it?

I like the originals fine. I like Dylan's rewrites far more. They have more meaning, more subtlety, more relevance to our time, and more intensity.

You're basically right to say that he's a pop singer, but he's a very unusual one, since he writes in a more serious vein than is normally seen in pop music.

He's simply a singer, in fact, who cannot be categorized. He sings pop, rock, blues, folk, country, and some other stuff too. The folk people got mad at him way back when after Newport '65, because they thought they owned him and that he would never disappoint them, but keep being their crown prince forever, and keep writing more of the same old stuff forever. When he threw away the folk crown and moved on, it truly upset them. Well, too bad. They didn't own him.

- LH


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Jack of Hearts
Date: 14 Mar 02 - 04:17 PM

dick greenhaus: "My question is can anyone identify a song that Dylan rewrote that's any better than the one he got it from?"

Dylan's "Fare Thee Well," a rewrite of "The Leaving of Liverpool" is, in my opinion, superior to the original. I suspect that Pete Seeger and Judy Collins might agree because they chose to record the Dylan rewrite rather than the traditional original.

Dylan's "A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall" has much more power, impact and continuing relevancy than "Lord Randall," the traditional ballad on which it is based.

There are many other examples and the value of Dylan's rewrites, in my opinion, do not negate the value of the traditional material.

dick greenhaus: "He hasn't had much to do with folk or trad. music in a long, long time."

That statement just shows that dick greenhaus has not been listening to what Bob Dylan has been dooing in a long, long time. When I saw him perform last month, Dylan did several traditional songs including "Duncan & Brady," (perhaps in tribute to the recently departed Dave Van Ronk).

Just a few years ago, Dylan did two albums of all traditional songs. Many of his recent songs are based on traditional styles and many contain references to traditional songs or characters from traditional songs. Listen to the epic "Tryin' To Get To Heaven" and then tell me that Dylan is not completely engrossed in traditional music.

Long ago, Pete Seeger said that he was wrong about being mad at Dylan for the electric set at Newport 37 years ago. It looks to me that dick greenhaus is among the last holdouts still bearing a grudge.

P.S. Lest anyone think that I am disrespecting dick greenhaus by not capitalizing his name, that is not the case. I am just following the style of how he, himself, presents his name in the above message.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: dick greenhaus
Date: 13 Mar 02 - 11:35 PM

Just to come at this from a different angle, let's assume (as I firmly believe) that using existing melodies is an essential part of the folk process. My question is can anyone identify a song that Dylan rewrote that's any better than the one he got it from?

DYlan was and is a consummate success as a pop singer. He's written a couple of very fine songs, some not-too-bad ones and a lot of garbage--a pretty fair batting average for any songwriter. In several cases (Blowin' in the Wind and Don't Think Twice for example) he's done enough re-writing of the source melody to earn a valid copyright (IMO).

He hasn't had much to do with folk or trad. music in a long, long time.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: kytrad (Jean Ritchie)
Date: 13 Mar 02 - 06:58 PM

"The Patriot Game" is based on, "The Nightengale," which is English in origin I believe (Irish may claim it, and it MAY be true)! As you know, it begins,

One morning, one morning, one morning in May,
I met a fair couple a-making their way,
And one was a lady, so sweet and so fair
And the other a soldier, a brave volunteer.

Lorraine Wyman collected, "Fair Nottamun Town," in Knott County, in our community. "Uncle" Jason Ritchie (actually Dad's first cousin, but all called him uncle)took her around to find singers, and sang several for her, himself. It was Uncle Jason who supplied his daughter Sabrina and her cousin (my sister Una- students atHindman Settlement School where Sharp and Karpeles were 'headquartering-' with all the lyrics and melody to, "Fair Nottamun Town," and, "The Little Devils."

My motivation for my "family copyrights" is in order to preserve sources of our songs, for folklore scholars of the present and future. I never require money for the use of these songs- only that they credit the source (of course, some do not ask for free usage, nor want it).

As to, Masters of War, I wanted only to ask Bob Dylan (then my friend, in the Greenwich Village folk group of those days)to honor the source of the melody, with something like, "Trad.Ritchie Family, KY." But lawyers take things out of one's hands...however, the "royalties" were a small out-of-court settlement- I never got any royalties since. And "words and music by Bob Dylan" was dropped in connection with the song (where the music should have a credit is left blank). I was satisfied with that, and I believe that Bob acted honorably with me.

I hope this answers all foregoing questions. Sincerely, Jean


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Little Hawk
Date: 13 Mar 02 - 03:57 PM

Yeah. I think Dylan generally only bothered to rework a trad song if he thought he could do something that was in some way an improvement on the original...or at least allowed him to say something he really wanted to say. If not, he didn't bother reworking it, but did it in its original form, albeit in his own style of delivery.

I've done the same thing myself, rewriting and adapting trad songs to new lyrics and new ideas, but no one objects to it...cos I'm not famous! :-)

Ah...the joys of anonymity... Several of Dylan's closest friends said recently, when asked what one present they would give him, if they could, that anonymity would be it.

Suze Rotolo said "youth, beauty, and no more biographies".

- LH


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: gloopy
Date: 13 Mar 02 - 05:53 AM

Hey, Little Hawk, Wow, someone here has read the liner notes on World Gone Wrong! Seeing that there seem to have been no accusations of stealing on any Dylan songs from about 1970 onward I assumed everyone had stopped listening! The World Gone Wrong liner notes are articulate and passionate, it seems that even though he felt the was nothing he could do to "improve" the songs on that album, he could still express himself in this other unexpected way, ie critic, and advocate. ps another reworking for ya'll is Blind Willie McTell from St James Imfirmary Blues (Approximately)


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Little Hawk
Date: 12 Mar 02 - 03:45 PM

Well said, gloopy. Bob does the same thing other folksingers have done since time immemorial. The difference is that when he does it everyone hears about it.

The liner notes to "World Gone Wrong" are the best evidence to support what you and I have said about this whole subject, but why would someone who hates Dylan bother to seek them out and read them? Most people would far rather stay mired in a comfortable and familiar rut of prejudice than exert a little mental effort, do some thoughtful investigation, and dig themselves out of it.

And it's a damn good thing no one has succeeded in copyrighting air and sunlight or we'd all be a whole lot worse off for it.

What Dylan earns money for is being creative in a unique way and entertaining people in a unique way, and you can't put a copyright on that nor is there any need to. When he dies, that particular show is over, and no one can start it up again.

- LH


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: gloopy
Date: 12 Mar 02 - 06:26 AM

Has anybody on this thread listened to Dylan's latest, Love and theft,he has a bit to say about the whole issue, albiet in a typically multi-layered way. Whole verses appear to have been lifted from the blues archives. High Water (for Charley Paton) refers to this in the title, but Paton doesn't get creditted for the lyrics. The predominate musical form is the 12 bar blues, but who would you credit with this. Dylan appears to be admitting both to stealing from what he loves, but indeed loving what it is he is stealing from. He is implying a similar accusation on his "fans" or "rivals" Dylan's reworkings have arguably always been written for an audience who actually know the originals, with no real attempt to hide it. (Bob takes the money thought) I'm sure he, in a way , he is sharing his love with the audience(Read the liner notes to World Gone Wrong if you dont believe me) If he could have copyrighted anything he would have been best served copyrighting his (unprotectable) vocal style, which has been subject to some of the most appalling copies imagining ps another cheeky "steal" is "Saved(by the Blood of the Lamb)" from another song entitled "saved"


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Little Hawk
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 08:40 PM

Duh...question? What question? We don't need no steenkin' questions to answer...

Wait a minute, I'll take a look... (consulting thread record above)

Ah yes, okay...well, I really can't help with that particular question, but there were some other posts that got me in gear, so...that's the way it goes.

There's always been a lot of bitching, backbiting, and cattiness in the music industry, just as in the film industry. It's a very competitive racket. Dylan mocked other people, they mocked him. Par for the course. I think what really irritated people about Bob was he kept surprising them, and succeeding at the same time.

- LH


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Noreen
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 08:02 PM

Judy, this thread had been dormant for almost two years until Deborah refreshed it yesterday with a new request for information about the melody for Lady Franklin's Lament. Little Hawk, at least, must have been aware of that, as he was the first to post after her request. He saw it as another chance to defend Mr. Zimmerman rather than actually adress the question, and others followed along well-trodden lines; that was my point.

No problem- her query is now being addressed elsewhere.

Noreen


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: JudyR
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 07:41 PM

Like someone else said -- forum subjects have a way of taking on a life of their own. I myself was well aware I wasn't responding to her original question. I thought that had been well-covered. Sandy -- sorry for spelling your last name wrong.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Noreen
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 07:18 PM

Deborah, you have re-opened a hornet's nest here... :0)

It would seem that you will be more likely to get an answer to your particular question by starting another thread, with the song in the title, so I'll do that for you: Source of melody:Lady Franklin's Lament?(Click here) to get to your new thread.

Noreen

(e-mail sent)

PS_ It would have been nice if some of you helpful people had actually read Deborah's question instead of jumping in again with both feet...


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: JudyR
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 06:56 PM

This is an interesting, if somewhat rambling passage by Eric Von Schmidt from "Baby Let Me Follow You Down," the book (1979).

"When we got to my apartment he wasn't much interested in playing; he wanted to listen. So I played "He Was a Friend of Mine,' 'Wasn't That A Mighty Storm,' 'Baby Let Me Lay It On You," and a couple of others. It was something, the way he was soaking up material in those days --like a sponge and a half. Later, somebody said, 'Hey, Bob's put one of your songs on his album.' They were talking about 'Baby Let Me Follow You Down' which had a spoken introduction saying he had heard it from me..'in the green fields of Harvard University.' The tune was the same, and the chores were real prety, but they weren't the same. I don't know if he changed them or if he'd heard a different version from Van Ronk. He also did Van Ronk's version of 'House of the Rising Sun' on that record, which pissed Dave off. The label on the record lists 'R. Von Schmidt' as he composer, but Witmark had copyrighted it under Dylan's name. I figured it was a good plug for me, so what the hell."

"The next time I saw Bob, he said, 'Hey man, that's your song,' or something..and sure enough, I got a contract signed by him listing us as co-composers. It was to become effective when I signed it. I called Manny Greenhill and explained the situation to him. He said, "Whatever you do, don't distort the facts, because you could get in trouble.' So Iwrote Witmark and gave them the 'facts' but explained that if we co-wrote the moment I signed the cntract, then we co-wrote it when the recored was released and royalties should start from there. They wrote back a note thanking me for my trouble and saying that I was right, I didn't have a claim to the song, and they were honoring 'a priori copyright." I figured they meant Blind Boy Fuller's heirs or something, but they were talking about Dylan's copyright. Apparantly they turned around with the "facts" I had supplied them and used them to void THAT copyright. A postscript to this all is that my ex-mentor, Manny Greenhill, now claism that the song was written by Reverend Gary Davis. Well, that's show biz."

Not sure who to attribute this mess to -- maybe not Dylan in the end? But these problems always seem to crop up with Dylan, don't they?! I don't know -- most of the arguments I could have made had been made by the time I got to this thread (and so much better, especially by Sandy Patton), but it seems to me there's just too many instances where Dylan, given a choice, made it in favor of himself (you know, if it walks like a duck, etc.) etc). At best, this convenient habit of taking material without credit is slipshod, at worst, somewhat shadowy and dubious.

Incidentally, Van Ronk WAS resentful of Dylan about "The House of the Rising Sun," I believe. for a long time. When I would hear him talk in the Village in the 70's, he often spoke of Dylan in somewhat mocking tones.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Little Hawk
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 12:46 PM

Yes, and it should have simply credited him with that particular arrangement of "Shenandoah"...assuming he was the one who arranged it.

But so what?

If one of the finest ships in the world pulled into your dock, would you refuse it on account of a couple of barnacles on the hull?

The only reason people bitch endlessly about Dylan is because his contribution to music has been so huge that they are incapable of ignoring him.

If his contribution had been minimal, and his degree of success likewise, you guys wouldn't care enough about him in the first place to bother seeking out minor blemishes to obsess about...and he wouldn't be any threat to your tender little egos, would he?

You're refusing a first class gift horse because it has one or two hairs out of place.

- LH


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Pixie
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 09:40 AM

I have a Bob Dylan song book that attributes words and music to "Shenandoah" to Bob......

Pixie


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Mr Red
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 09:31 AM

dick greenhaus
Bitchy, bitchy - but so true.
Mike Regenstreif
Nat Hentoff said it and not Dylan, who took the dosh?
Whistle Stop
If Dylan was borrowing from all around and he never got sued for plagiarism then, I sumbit - ladies and gentlemen of the kangaroo jury, it is a coincidence beyond chance.
call me a cynic, but I read the Kline biog and Woody's autobiography and Woody was ALWAYS referring to his "borrowing" of tunes. So how close, artistically/morally, to Woody did old zimmerframe get?
Roy Palmer sees no crime in "not giving credit" if the record company get all the financial credit.
I say "OK, so we'll be their conscience."
Here endeth my Scarborough (notso) Fair Canticle
AND that's another thing..........


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Little Hawk
Date: 10 Mar 02 - 12:48 AM

You're repeating yourself, Dick. You provided that same quote (but not in quotation marks) way back on 12 May 00 at 3:15 PM on this very same thread...

Did Bob Dylan kick your dog once or something? You can compare Johnny Rotten to a kid writing on bathroom walls...or any number of heavy metal, punk, rap, and alternative songwriters, who swear constantly onstage to titillate their prepubescent audiences...but Dylan? I don't think so.

I am reminded of Mick Jagger, who once said of Madonna "a teaspoonful of talent in a sea of ambition"...

Now, I'm no Madonna fan, but in both cases I see a quite clever use of words, making a statement that is funny, snide, and has little if any actual bearing on the subject at hand, though in Madonna's case the part about the ambition was quite correct.

If you and Mick got together, I bet you could think up a few more of these devastating one-liners, and with any luck attain a certain form of immortality thereby...at least among a very limited audience.

- LH


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: dick greenhaus
Date: 09 Mar 02 - 09:57 PM

I remember a comment from many years ago about how someone "drew upon folk music the way little boys draw on lavatory walls". Not Bob, of course.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Little Hawk
Date: 09 Mar 02 - 08:20 PM

I don't think I know of anyone who has taken the heart and soul of traditional music and adapted it more faithfully and powerfully to fresh new lyrics and modern images and themes. Dylan's love of traditional music is evident throughout his career and is one of his great strengths. To hear him do a trad song on acoustic guitar is a joy. Some of his concert performances of same are absolute gems. We can all be grateful that he tapped into the folk tradition at an early age, and absorbed it like a sponge...as he also did with country, rock 'n roll, and acoustic blues.

Dylan respects the past and has not forgotten it, but built marvelously upon it.

If, on the other hand, you look at the music videos which are prevalent today you might wonder if the people who made most of them are aware of any past at all...or are just trying desperately to be "cool" in a way that is about as ephemeral, and valuable, as soap bubbles. Give 'em an explosive dance beat, a overwhelming deluge of bass end, and lyrics that are repetitive throwaway garbage...and you've got a hit! Blaugh! It's Desolation Row out there in TV land.

- LH


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST
Date: 09 Mar 02 - 06:29 PM

I am trying to find the source of the melody to which Lord Franklin (or Lady Franklin's Lament) was written. I know, as you must also, that one of Bob Dylan's early hits used not only the melody but whole lines, i.e. I dreamed a dream and I thought it true of all the friends that I ever knew. I think that Ewan MacColl recorded it. He may have written the tune but it appears that there were earlier versions. Might you have information about this or a suggestion as to where I might go to trace the use of a melody that was probably in the public domain. Thank you. Deborah Parducci dparducci28@compuserve.com


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: bbelle
Date: 21 May 00 - 11:43 AM

Guest,RJE ... since you purport to know Dylan personally, ask him this, for me ... "Did Diamonds and Rust really happen?" Also ask him if he's using an analog wireless phone or digital wireless phone. If he says "digital," tell him to be sure it's cdma technology so his conversations can't be cloned ... Jenny


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Terry K
Date: 21 May 00 - 07:04 AM

John Twomey - I wish I'd said that!!

And 'spaw, - I wish I'd said that!!


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: catspaw49
Date: 21 May 00 - 01:40 AM

Hey, I know the Pope personally and I just called him up on his cell phone and he said it was OK if women entered the priesthood, never understood the significance of "Hail Mary" until he had doled out 34,917 as a young priest, and asked if I could send him a pack of rubbers. He also said that after reading the ridiculous tripe by GuestRJE, he has changed his mind on abortion.

Spaw


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,RJE
Date: 21 May 00 - 01:22 AM

I know Bob Dylan personally, and I just called him up on his cell phone and asked him if he ever stole any songs and he said, emphapticaly, that he never stole one f'ing song. He said he didn't even know what copyright meant till his third album and never understood what Public Domain meant till he recorded Diamond Joe and that stuff.He also said you people ought to get a life or write a song of your own or something.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Rick Fielding
Date: 21 May 00 - 12:39 AM

or Blind Willie McTell for "Georgia Rag" (copied from Blake's "Wabash Rag") or Tampa Red (under a pseud) stealing his own "Tight Like That". Or Gene Autrey's astonishingly accurate lifting of a lot of Jimmie Rodgers' songs. Well maybe they might if they knew about it.

Rick


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,BluTrane
Date: 21 May 00 - 12:38 AM

No, Ole Mole, those guys were Black,so the white phoneys, I mean folkies, wouldn't be surprised by their theivin ways...they'd rather lambast Dylan for doin what musicians have been doin since the first song was written, er stolen.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: TheOldMole
Date: 21 May 00 - 12:23 AM

Do people on this thread feel equally angry with Elmore James for "Dust My Broom," with Willie Dixon for "My Babe" (This Train)? With Muddy Waters for "I Can't Be Satisfied"? If not, why not?


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,John Twomey
Date: 21 May 00 - 12:02 AM

I belive that any one who loves music and claims to have no respect for Bob Dylan has serious psychological problems and issues that they haven't dealt with. Anyone who knows even a modicum about traditional music knows that this type of criticism of Dylan is not about music but about resentment and jealousy.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Okiemockbird
Date: 20 May 00 - 12:53 PM

Copying from the public domain is not per se plagiarism. The public domain is meant to be copied. I consider it praiseworthy to copy and/or imitate and/or modify good works in the public domain. "Plagiarism", as I define it, contains a conclusion about the motives of the copyist, not just an observation of the fact of copying. For plagiarism to exist as I define it, there needs to be some deception or bad faith present, not just copying. The position taken by many in this thread, as interpreted through the filter of my definition of plagiarism, is that if Dylan had acknowledged his sources openly, there would be fewer doubts about his good faith or lack of it.

T.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Mrbisok@aol
Date: 20 May 00 - 06:46 AM

This Dylan thread could form the basis of a PhD thesis. Remember when Martin L. King's PhD thesis was found to contain heavy borrowings? Exposing pop culture ikons is all the rage in our celebrity-driven culture: Idea: make a million: write an anti-Dylan book: "Bob Dylan: Plagiarist."


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Okiemockbird
Date: 19 May 00 - 10:33 AM

Sandy, this link gives Jean Ritchie's account of her copyright claim.

My understanding is: since the melody was published in Cecil Sharp's collection, republication of exactly the same melody in a later book doesn't affect the copyright (or lack of it) in the melody.

T.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Syd, Ottawa
Date: 19 May 00 - 12:45 AM

"Restless Farewell" (on "The Times They Are A-Changing") is a reworking of a traditional Irish Song called "The Parting Glass".

Dominic Behan did write "The Patriot Game" - at least he wrote the words. The events described in the song date, I believe, from 1959. I suspect the tune is older and had been recycled from an earlier traditional Irish song.

Syd


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Sandy Paton
Date: 18 May 00 - 10:14 PM

I always thought Jean Ritchie's claim to "Nottamun Town" was based on the publication of the song in her Singing Family of the Cumberlands, for which copyright was clearly established when it was published. The Lomax and Warner claim to "Tom Dooley" was, I think, based on a similar claim, since Lomax got the song from Warner and published it long before the great folk scare began. Am I all wet on this?

Also, I thought Dominic Behan was the source of "The Patriot Game." Everyone in the London folk scene of 1958 seemed to consider it "his" song. Can someone locate the "very old" appearance Guest James refers to above?

I'm pleased to learn of Dylan's note on his use of "Lord Franklin" that Mike points to above. I only wish similar notes had been written concerning his sources for those other splendid tunes he came up with. Not to deny him the use of tunes in the public domain, merely wishing that he had given the tradition credit when and where it was due. I'd like folks to realize how beautiful some of our traditional tunes are. It might encourage them to investigate them further.

Sandy


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,James
Date: 18 May 00 - 11:38 AM

This is a note to Sandy, although I hear undertones of this in other threads..Dylan did use Nottamun Town"s tune and probably her heard it from the singinh of Jean Ritchie. However, Ms Ritchie heard it elswhere obviously ,because it is a very old tune and is one that is used in many traditional English songs. As for his using the tune to The Patriot Game...that is also a very old tune than was comandeered for use . So it is truly the folk process in action rather than "theft". Personally, I love to see a good tune revived.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Whistle Stop
Date: 18 May 00 - 11:29 AM

I recognize your motives in starting this thread, but like all threads it has taken on a life of its own. There were clearly some disparaging remarks about Dylan's failure to credit his sources, and his use of the standard notation "Words and Music by Bob Dylan" on material that was built on borrowed melodies. And of course, it's Dylan, so there were the usual gratuitous references to his "nasal whine" and take-no-prisoners professional ambition. I defended his honor, not against attacks that you launched, but against comments that others made which I considered unfair.

This is called "thread creep" -- happens a lot around here. Some object to it, but I think it keeps things interesting.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Okiemockbird
Date: 18 May 00 - 10:59 AM

I get the impression that some are attacking a straw man. As I read, no one contributing to this thread, with one doubtful exception, has criticized Dylan or anyone else merely for using public domain material. I, at least, consider it commendable of Dylan to have engaged in the so-called "folk process" in this way. My original inquiry was simply to get opinions about Dylan's sources. The thread has since developed to address the etiquette of creative copying, addressing in particular the question of acknowledgement of sources. But I have looked this thread over more than once, and I can't find anyone clearly condemning creative copying per se.

Speaking of creative copying, this page was recently mentioned on a copyright-related web site at Harvard. It demonstrates Handel's use of another composer's melody.

T.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: zander (inactive)
Date: 18 May 00 - 10:23 AM

There is nothing wrong in borrowing tunes or song ideas, this has always happened in folk music either accidently or on purpose it is called the folk process, but when someone knows the origin it is only polite to give credit where it is due. Bob Dylan sometimes did this but not always, Paul Simon was a worse culprit, IE. Scarborough Fair. Best regards to all, Dave


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Terry K
Date: 18 May 00 - 12:22 AM

It bothers me that some people seem to think Dylan perhaps should not have released some of his tracks or should somehow not have been allowed to - thus robbing us of them. (A world without "Don't think twice" ? - unthinkable).

I'm for anything that EXPANDs music and against anything that would tend to restrict.

And as for the commercial aspects - does anyone really believe that Bobbie himself had much influence over contract/copyright issues?


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Mike Regenstreif
Date: 17 May 00 - 05:22 PM

I'm not sure that Bob Dylan himself ever tried to hoodwink anyone about his use of traditional melodies (a lesson he learned from the likes of Guthrie, Seeger, and many others).

I just pulled out my copy of THE FREEWHEELIN' BOB DYLAN, his second album, from 1963.

In the liner notes discussion about Bob Dylan's Dream, Nat Hentoff talks about Dylan getting the idea for the lyrics after an all-night discussion with Oscar Brown, Jr. and goes on to say: "The song slumbered, however, until Dylan went to England in the winter of 1962. There he heard a singer, whose name he recalls as Martin Carthy, perform Lord Franklin, and that old melody found a new adapted home in Bob Dylan's Dream."

Mike Regenstreif


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Jim the Bart
Date: 17 May 00 - 11:59 AM

The one thing worse than having someone else get credit for something that you know is yours, is that sick feeling you get when someone points out to you that something you thought was yours actually came from somewhere else. It is so easy to unconsciously plagiarize. And when your focus is on lyric rather than melody, as I believe was true for Mr. Dylan early on, you don't always realize that you borrowed/used/incorporated/stole the melody that fit the words so well.
One other thing that I think should be considered in this discussion is the nature of the music business back in the 60's. Bob Dylan the "singer/songwriter" probably finished the recording, tossed the lyric sheets to Albert Grossman who turned them over to a lawyer who filed the copywrite documents without ever questioning if anyone else should be credited. I doubt that too many people at that time, even true believers, would have imagined that someone 40 years later would be questioning the derivation of the melody line on Farewell Angelina. Although people should not be excused for things done in their name, I also don't think it's fair to assume that Dylan willfully took credit that he knew wasn't his. And at this late date, I doubt that he feels much of a need to correct the record. I'm glad that you guys are doing it, though. I was not aware of the specific derivations of some of these tunes and it's interesting to find out the truth.
As far as Lay Down That Weary Tune - there is a superficial similarity to the River is Wide, but I don't think they're the same song. Of course, I have been wrong before. . .


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: GUEST,Okiemockbird
Date: 17 May 00 - 09:36 AM

I get the impression from a document linked above that it's Jean Ritchie who is trying to leverage her copyright to some new lyrics to "Nottamun Town" into a copyright over the Ritchie version of the melody. I don't know how else to account for her reference to having collected royalties from Bob Dylan, though there may be other explanations (e.g. maybe Dylan sometimes performed Jean's words.)

Those of you who, like McGrath and Grandma Marshall (may I call you "Bábushka" ?) and Sandy believe that "Songs are there to be used to make new songs" might want to reply (on or off forum) to this inquiry which was recently posted to the CNI Copyright Forum.

T.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Whistle Stop
Date: 17 May 00 - 08:46 AM

Sandy, I like to think it's possible to enrich both your pocketbook and your soul. This may be an illusion, but I'd like to hang onto it anyway.

Dylan always seems to inspire strong feelings in people. Lots of people don't like his singing, and many feel he has too much "attitude". I also think that some folks resent his success, and there may be a touch of animosity lingering from his treasonous behavior at Newport. For myself, I love his voice, which I find very expressive, and find no fault with his attitude. He "made it big," and he pursued his own vision, and offers no apologies for either. There are a number of other singers and songwriters out there who would have liked to succeed as he has, but didn't. That doesn't mean they were more virtuous than he was, as comforting as that thought might be.

I love simple folk melodies, but let's be honest -- a lot of these tunes are pretty similar when you come right down to it, and it's sometimes hard to tell where one diatonic scale/three chord folk tune ends and another begins. In my humble opinion people should stop worrying about Dylan's use of building blocks from other songs -- unless and until he tries to prevent others from using the same building blocks he has used. If anyone has any evidence that he has tried to stop other people from borrowing tunes as he has, I'd love to hear it.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Sandy Paton
Date: 17 May 00 - 12:46 AM

No reason to apologize for holding a different opinion. What kind of discussion could we have without those differences? But, what was that old saying, Rick, about "two wrongs not making a right?" Neither do seven or eight. I am often inclined to despise the commercial music business. Imagine making music to enrich your pocketbook rather than your soul.

Sandy


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Sandy Paton
Date: 17 May 00 - 12:28 AM

What was that old saying, Rick, about "two wrongs not making... etc.?" Neither do seven or eight.

Sandy


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: paddyc
Date: 16 May 00 - 10:49 PM

Dylan used to hang out with the Clancys in 1960's and borrowed alot of their irish stuff to make his own tunes.


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate

Subject: RE: Dylan's use of Trad music?
From: Margaret V
Date: 16 May 00 - 10:03 PM

Just for the record, Spaw, "Bob Dylan's Dream" is pretty powerful and moving even to those of us who were just sprouts in the '60s! Or at any rate, it is to me. . . Margaret


Post - Top - Home - Printer Friendly - Translate
Next Page

  Share Thread:
More...

Reply to Thread
Subject:  Help
From:
Preview   Automatic Linebreaks   Make a link ("blue clicky")


Mudcat time: 24 February 7:09 PM EST

[ Home ]

All original material is copyright © 1998 by the Mudcat Café Music Foundation, Inc. All photos, music, images, etc. are copyright © by their rightful owners. Every effort is taken to attribute appropriate copyright to images, content, music, etc. We are not a copyright resource.