Mudcat Café message #3887893 The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #162666   Message #3887893
Posted By: Jim Carroll
10-Nov-17 - 12:11 PM
Thread Name: New Book: Folk Song in England
Subject: RE: New Book: Folk Song in England
If I despaired I wouldn't bother arguing Brian
I too respect the work of those you mention and am tired of these discussions ending up in cat-fights, but I believe traditional songs to be important enough to get things right - it's been gotten wrong so often before.
For me, one of the most fundamental things has been whether singers were also composers, as I believe they were.
I too got enormous pleasure from listening to Sam, Harry, Walter, et al, and from singing the songs (I sill do), but taken as a whole, the tradition is far wider than that,
The overturning of an entire belief, over a century's research seems so important a step as not to be taken lightly and certainly without examining all the facts and implications
I can't see any other way other than thrash it out - sorry
Jim