Mudcat Café message #3243501 The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #140399   Message #3243501
Posted By: Jim Carroll
23-Oct-11 - 10:00 AM
Thread Name: BS: Palestine
Subject: RE: BS: Palestine
"cited ~ NOT originated " "shooting the messenger".
And I repeat, there is no messenger nobody anywhere has attempted to implicate the whole Pakistani male population in cultural degeneracy apart from Keith; he has not produced one single example of anybody doing so; in fact, the several 'examples' he did put up state the opposite; that there are no cultural/racial conclusions to be drawn from the opinions offered
As has been pointed out by others, the implications of what he (and he alone - with your blessing) has claimed go far beyond the Pakistani population and can be applied to Muslims as a whole, including the Palastinians.
At the risk of incuring your wrath further - isn't this exactly what happened to the Jews under the Nazis?
On the basis of "scientific and academic evidence" proving that Jews were culturally and genetically degenerate they justified sending six million of them to the gas chambers.
Keith hasn't 'gone all the way' by any means, but it is a step on the road as far as I am concerned - his "my opinion" is profoundly racist and it is this you have given your blessing to by claiming it otherwise.
It is also you who has chosen to play the race card in this discussion on Palestine - shame on you.
Jim Carroll