Mudcat Café message #2238096 The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #107010   Message #2238096
Posted By: dick greenhaus
16-Jan-08 - 08:08 PM
Thread Name: Songs of Elizabeth Cronin - to be reissued
Subject: RE: Songs of Elizabeth Cronin - to be reissued
Russ-
The review was not a "negative view of a traditional musician"--it was a negative view of some sloppy research and writing. And I agree that the tone was unnecessarily harsh....but the objections stated were certainly valid ones.